Poisonous pesticides, soil pollution and water waste: high-street fashion has a lot to answer for in the environmental game.
But can big brands use their global clout to drive the green revolution?
If green is the new black on the high-street, then global retailers are lining up to parade their eco-credentials, from Marks and Spencers in Britain, to sportswear behemoth Nike or the fashion giant H&M.
“There’s a paradigm shift in the textile sector,” John Mowbray, editor of the green trends magazine Ecotextile, told AFP at the Texworld trade fair in Paris this month.
“Three years ago sustainability was not on the agenda” he says. “Now a lot of retailers and brands want to move regardless of what their suppliers think. They think consumers want transparency. Brands are driving change.”
Sourcing cleaner fabrics — from organic yarns to recycled polyester —and rooting out sweatshop practices in Asia and elsewhere are the twin planks of the sustainability mantra adopted by many of the West’s top brands.
And the most visible example of this is organic cotton.
Until recently an expensive rarity, organic cotton t-shirts are cropping up on supermarket and bargain retail shelves, from Tesco or Topshop in Britain to Auchan in France or Primark in the United States.
Global retail sales of organic cotton apparel and home textile goods have been soaring 40 per cent per year since 2001, according to the Organic Exchange (OE) non-profit group.
The world’s top 10 organic-cotton using brands last year, according to the OE, reads like a Who’s Who of the high-street fashion and sports industry, including C&A, Nike, Walmart, H&M, Levi Strauss & Co and Adidas.
The global organic cotton market is still a baby, making up one percent of the total harvest. But the market is booming — and the growth appears recession-proof.
Organic cotton production grew 20 percent in 2008/09 over 2007/08, across India, Turkey, Pakistan and 19 other countries, with growth forecast to continue at 20 to 40 percent through 2011.
Last year, even as the economic slowdown sliced seven per cent off the global apparel and textiles market, the organic segment grew by 35 per cent, with sales of 4.3 billion dollars.
“We weren’t affected by the crisis,” said HL Ding, a Chinese entrepreneur whose natural fibre firm Hemp Fortex turned over 10 million dollars in 2009 selling to the likes of Walmart. “We’re a small part of a market that’s still growing.”
Short of going organic, meanwhile, dozens of brands and retailers — who together consume 15 percent of the world’s cotton—have signed up to a global scheme called the Better Cotton Initiative.
Aiming to cut water and soil pollution while battling child and bonded labour, it involves 100,000 cotton farmers in China, Central Asia, Brazil and West and Central Africa.
Retail giants Ikea and Levi Strauss sit on the council of the scheme, whose first crop is set for harvest in the coming months.
‘Organic cotton, yes, but at what price?’
So the figures are impressive. But how much is this really doing to reduce the industry’s ethical footprint? Is this real change or mere “greenwashing”?
“Sure, they are buying organic cotton, but at what price, and how is it made?” warned Isabel Quehe, founder of the Ethical Fashion Show which was holding its seventh edition in Paris this week.
Looking beyond fabrics, “consumers need to think about where their clothes come from, whether the person who made them was paid a living wage.”
Just this week, a report in France’s Liberation newspaper exposed the “prison-like” conditions in a textile complex in southern India that supplies many of the West’s top brands, like Gap or H&M.
“I saw an organic t-shirt selling for 2.90 euros — at that kind of price you can only be producing it in terrible conditions,” said Christan Tournafol, one of the designers at the Paris show whose label Les Racines du Ciel sources organic fibres around the world.
But there was also evidence at the Texworld fair that support from big retail partners is helping green, ethical suppliers to thrive.
Some 120 certified organic and fair-trade fabric suppliers made the trip to Paris this year —double the number a year ago.
“It’s not easy for companies to transform themselves,” says Bernd Muller, in charge of sustainable textiles at the show.
“There have been problems with whole villages who converted to organic, and ended up with unsold cotton on their hands,” added the fair’s managing director Marie-Armelle de Bouteiller.
A case in point: JCT Limited ships a million yards of organic yarn each year from the Indian Punjab to clients including Nike and Decathlon.