Church of Uganda says URA should have referred its proposal for consideration by Parliament before proceeding to implement it.
He said they would now sell a prayer book at UShs18,000 (Sh485), up from UShs15,000 (Sh404).
The price of a Bible ranges from UShs23,000 to UShs32,000, (Sh620-862) according to Uganda Bible Society records.
Kampala
The Uganda Revenue Authority (URA) has reversed a long-standing tradition and ordered religious groups to start paying taxes on Bibles, Korans, prayer and hymn books.
Clerics across faith groups Monday reacted to the proposal with consternation and disbelief, insisting the religious materials should be tax-exempt since they use them for “spiritual nourishment” of Ugandans. However, the URA commissioner general, Ms Doris Akol, disagreed, saying the practice of not taxing the entities and materials was in the first place “an anomaly”.
“We understand that Value-Added Tax (VAT) has in the past not been paid on the said Bibles, prayer books and hymn books. This was an anomaly,” she wrote in an April 19 letter.
Ms Akol was responding to a petition a month earlier by the Church of Uganda Archbishop Stanley Ntagali. The prelate had asked the tax man to release a consignment of 9,120 prayer and hymn books imported from Nairobi, Kenya, without the church having to pay VAT.
In his March 18 letter, Archbishop Ntagali noted that items had been shipped in by Centenary Publishing House Limited, Church of Uganda’s (CoU) publishing arm, which in his view should be tax-exempt.
Church’s appeal “It is from this point of view that we write to you, appealing that the VAT be waived... since they (books) are used to educate the masses and Christians by spreading the word of God as our nation’s motto affirms, ‘For God and my country,” he stated. Ms Akol said she had no power to waive a tax not excluded under the law and, as such, URA released the consignment only after CoU paid UShs8.9m (Sh240,000).
In a country where nine out of every 10 citizens are either Christians or Muslims, the proposed tax that a church official said would result in increase of, for instance, a hymn books’ cost by UShs3,000 (Sh80).
If enforced, it also means the government could raise substantial revenues from taxes on religious materials. The religious institutions were unable to immediately provide the number of Bibles, Korans and other worship materials sold in a year.
Mr Joshua Kitakule, the secretary general of the Inter-Religious Council of Uganda, an umbrella body of different faiths, yesterday said whereas religions should not entirely be tax-exempt, imposing 18 per cent VAT on Bibles, Korans and prayer books would be “erroneous”.
“These items are not meant for profit; so, it is erroneous to tax them. Prayer books are supposed to strengthen the spiritual nourishment of individuals,” he said. The tax body’s break from tradition followed months of engagement with religious leaders who remained opposed to the proposal.
For instance, Mr Ramathan Mugalu, the secretary general of the Uganda Muslim Supreme Council, said President Museveni had said all imported prayer materials that are not for sale should not be taxed. “This government has gone too far in its collection of taxes. How can you tax the word of God? It should instead come in to assist in publishing these materials,” Mr Mugalu said.
Parliament issue Canon Joram Kahenano, a CoU commissioner, said URA should have referred its proposal for consideration by Parliament before proceeding to implement it. He said they would now sell a prayer book at Shs18,000, up from Shs15,000. The price of a Bible ranges from Shs23,000 to Shs32,000, according to Uganda Bible Society records.
“We are at the end of the Financial Year; URA should have taken a tax proposal to Parliament,” Canon Kahenano said. Mr Jim Mugunga, the Finance ministry spokesperson, said URA was widening the tax base. “It is not uncommon for URA to bring to the fold persons, items and entities within tax base. It is its mandate to implement tax collection,” Mr Mugunga said.
“URA is not a monster; it is their mandate to engage with the affected entities,” he added. The government has also proposed to impose new taxes, including on social media users in the next Financial Year as Uganda struggles to wean itself off donors.
